Beta testing FloatHub boat monitoring, and the wonders of marine WiFi

... written for Panbo by Ben Ellison and posted on Jul 18, 2017

FloatHub_yellow_box_beta_testing_on_Gizmo_cPanbo.jpg

I don't usually write about beta testing, but the FloatHub monitoring system is already proving itself so smart and functional that I want its Kickstarter campaign to succeed and hope that some readers enjoy the good deal that seems available, at least for the next few days. Detailing FloatHub is also a good opportunity to discuss the many ways WiFi is being used afloat these days, a subject that many boaters are understandably confused about...

FloatHub_boat_monitoring_main_online_dashboard_cPanbo.jpgFirst, here's a visual taste of what the yellow hardware box and lots of associated beta software are doing for me right now, as seen on the FloatHub dashboard browser page I can open on my computers, tablet or phone (click the screen bigger for detail). The "00:43" highlighted at lower right means that FloatHub uploaded fresh data from the boat to the Internet cloud just 43 seconds before the screenshot, and that's not unusual. There are issues with using WiFi for off-boat monitoring -- like its ability to help when you're anchored in remote islands -- but it can often update automatically, frequently and richly without the extra costs cellular and satellite incur.

Once powered up and online, and without any further wiring, FloatHub provides the GPS info you see above, as well as the air temperature (which needs calibration, at least for my sample hardware) and barometric pressure (quite accurate). A simple jumper gets you the 12v feed voltage, and then it's just a matter of running small gauge 1-amp fused wires to get five more voltage readings -- be they battery banks, charge sources, or whatever -- plus three voltage on/off states that are time monitored so you can track when, and for how long, pumps and similar are activated.

Also, if I'd been able to get the FloatHub's standard speed NMEA 0183 input working right -- the culprit has not been identified yet, but likely local to Gizmo -- my dashboard could be showing current wind, depth, and water temperature conditions at the boat. Moreover, all this data gets logged in the secure FloatHub cloud and can be seen graphically just by clicking on the little button lower left, and the dashboard already has a lot of clever interactive interface features which you can best check out at this FloatHub demo page.

By the way, I've already suggested to the FloatHub team that what they're calling Bearing is actually COG (Course over Ground from GPS) and is best expressed as null when the boat is moored or anchored, and also that it's preferable to portray the boat icon without bow orientation in such circumstances (unless Heading is being sent). But this is an impressively minor detail for a system that won't deliver to KickStarter backers until October at earliest.

iPad_and_EasyBullet_seen_WiFi_hotspots_on_Gizmo_in_Camden_cPanbo.jpgTo best understand how to set up FloatHub and what it can do, it's good to know the differences between WiFi client and access point (AP) modes, both of which can be done simultaneously by the yellow FH box. But understanding WiFi client/AP distinctions has become important on many boats anyway, so let's dig into the two (somewhat extreme) Gizmo iPad screens above.

At left is the list of WiFi access points that my iPad sees from Gizmo's main cabin while moored in (admittedly tight and WiFi-dense) Camden Inner Harbor. Some of those AP's are ashore, some on other boats, and the ones marked with blue dots are right on Gizmo herself, though no location guarantees that any access point actually accesses the Internet (even if many landlubbers presume that all WiFi APs do). For instance, the "Garmin-7612..." and "GoFree WiFi..." APs listed only access the associated navigation systems (which can be very useful), while the "Gizmo_RAYeS127..." has a sophisticated dual WiFi nature. But the highly-used "MV gizmo cmw" often is an Internet AP because it's connected to the high-power Coastal Marine WiFi "bridge" mounted on Gizmo's mast.

To see all the APs that CMW's reprogrammed Ubquiti Bullet can see -- the list of 42 hotspots ordered by signal strength at right above -- I use CMW's EasyBullet app on the iPad or another device logged onto the CMW router. And once I select an able hotspot, like the beauty I'm using here in Camden, every device connected to the router is online. Now I've been yammering about these sort of boat WiFi systems for years (and tried to diagram the concept here along with cell booster strategies), and I'm happy to report that they are often now so solid that they can support always-on monitoring systems like FloatHub.

In fact, what you don't see on these lists are several WiFi devices on Gizmo that are only in client mode and doing good work while logged into the "MV gizmo cmv" router. For instance, an interface with the long-tested Vesper XB8000 AIS transceiver is invariably available to iPad and PC over Wifi (no matter if there's also an Internet connection) and, in fact, that interface has gotten so valuable with the recent Smart AIS updates that I modified my helm setups (story coming). Meanwhile, the GoFree Track monitoring system also being tested has tenaciously stayed online via the CMW WiFi for many months, even collecting trip track data and auto uploading it whenever the router is back online again, a neat trick that FloatHub will also purportedly perform (as the dashboard develops).

FloatHub_onboard_private_WiFi_setup.jpgThe primary reason that FloatHub also offers its own hotspot is so that you can tell it how to get online and do other setup chores. In Gizmo's case FloatHub's "Public" network is set as the boat's router and may never need change, but on a simpler boat you might go here to change hotspots as you change harbors. I also personalized the "Private" local network name from the default "FloatHub" (maybe because multiple Gizmo hotspots are a perverse form of harbor bling).

I prefer "Onboard" and "Off boat" to FloatHub's "Public" and "Private" wireless network terminology, especially since all aspects of FloatHub seem to be carefully protected. Note, for instance, the hard-to-break account settings you have to enter once you've established an online service plan (which happily start at $0 per month). And, besides, standard terms for these different ways to use WiFi on a boat, or even in your Internet of Things (IoT) home, have not yet taken hold.

FloatHub_streaming_boat_data_to_iNavX_cPanbo.jpgHere's another reason to have a "GizmoFloatHub" access point. Even when a FloatHub is not online (but still logging data for when it is), it can gateway data from its own sensors and its NMEA 0183 inputs over WiFi to various nav apps on a tablet or phone (as we recently discussed). And while I've been having trouble using Vesper XB8000 0183 output to test this feature, it has worked occasionally.

For instance, the screens above show how iNavX instrument settings were set to the specific IP address and port where data is served from the GizmoFloatHub AP, and the data stream was confirmed first by the obtuse green NMEA sentences streaming low on the setup screen and then by actual Depth, Wind, etc. values showing up in instrument windows...at least for a while.

In fact, that data was first generated by Gizmo's NMEA 2000 sensors and then gatewayed to 0183 by the Vesper XB, which should work but may be my problem. Plan B is to try the amazing Rose Point NEMO everything gateway which I've just started testing, but I already suspect that FloatHub handles more normal 0183 inputs fine and, besides, its innovation is really in the off boat monitoring area.

FloatHub_vessel n device_settings_cPanbo.jpgSetting up a FloatHub dashboard is pleasantly easy and the possibilities are many, especially when you realize that the Battery, Charger, and Pump categories are really just suggestions. For instance, I'm using the pump timing feature to keep an eye on Gizmo's Lumishore underwater lights, because it's a little too easy to leave them on at night, and also because I'm experimenting with remote control (talk about harbor bling).

But I'll also note that some of that monitoring above is still aspirational. For example, I still haven't run a wire from the FloatHub to where the boat's solar panels cable into the Blue Sky controller, and first I need to check that the raw voltage output fits within FH parameters. And maybe you wonder how am I monitoring the status of the Victron inverter -- which can also be proxy for shore power -- using DC 12v voltage? That's a neat trick I'll explain when I review the now installed SkyMate Mazu Sentry monitoring system.

FloatHub_boat_monitoring_main_alert_settings_cPanbo.jpgThe FloatHub dashboard is useful and will get more so, but the heart of effective boat monitoring is a well-designed alert feature, and FH's rules-based system works well in my experience. For instance, I don't get false low battery alerts due to spikes caused by Gizmo's refrigeration because I could easily tell FloatHub not to bother unless the condition persisted for 10 minutes (and maybe, too, because FloatHub's voltage logging seems well smoothed).

Using time as a factor with time-based "pump" alerts seems trickier. So I think that my alert for underwater lights being on more than an hour over a two-hour period will fire off after two hours, but only lights-on time will tell, and it will be easy to change as needed.

FloatHub_online_dashboard_graphs_cPanbo.jpgHere's my current FloatHub dashboard graph view. Among other virtues, it's the best view I have of what's happening over time with Gizmo's FireFly battery bank, which I've been stressing with lots of install hours and 24/7 loads -- including several other good monitoring systems -- versus little engine charging (the high voltage spikes), let alone underway time (the SOG spikes). I look forward to when I can view this data by day or week (like the FloatHub demo) and especially to when FloatHub starts auto logging the trips I'm about to make more of.

FloatHub_logged_data_not_yet_in_dashboard_cPanbo.jpgThor Sigvaldason of FloatHub, and the project's mother company Modiot Labs, sent me the screens above to illustrate the data detail already being collected from Gizmo's beta yellow box, and from what I've seen so far it's not hard to imagine how nicely it will be displayed on future editions of the FH dashboard.

Other future possibilities are FloatHub support for Signal K boat data -- did you see the Code Afloat contest announcement? -- and note that FH is already "eminently user hackable and extensible" with open source code and a simple data protocol already as clearly explained as the less geeky of us will find the FloatHub guides and manuals.

I realize that I've gotten a little nuts about boat monitoring, but I think I'm onto something that can provide more pleasure and less worry to the boat owning experience. I'm also learning that WiFi can be a viable boat monitoring medium and if your boat lives somewhere like my harbor, please consider backing the FloatHub Kickstarter campaign.

FoatHub open home at Modiot Labs cPanbo.jpg

Comments

Great review and interesting product
For "shore power" monitoring. Whilst it's possible to use chargers etc as a proxy
For Presence of mains power,
I find the simplest and most foolproof method ... a miniature mains relay,
Wired across a mains/shore power circuit
The relay contacts can be configured using either normally open or closed, and
Can Switch to negative or positive voltage - so infinitely configurable for any type of telemetry/monitoring device input.

The power consumption (the relay coil) is minuscule - and only present when the shore
Power connected (or generator running) .. and the relay contacts can be used for multiple purposes ... even in the simplest config, to wire a LED as a simple visual monitor (for those of us lucky to be able to see our boats from the back door :)
A suitable relay a few $s only at hobbyist shop or online.

Posted by: gregy at July 19, 2017 7:48 PM | Reply

It’s easy to get nuts about boat monitoring and it seems like it’s taken a long time for the industry to get competitive and offer interesting alternatives. I think the first question to ask is what are your needs, and how do you operate your boat. If you just want to see what it’s doing on the dock, on shore power, on a reliable wifi network then you can really go nuts. If you want to watch your boat while in new and perhaps faraway places I would argue you have to keep it simple. Relying on wifi, and having to keep it and any components of your NEMA network powered up are simply non-starters in remote places. I personally have begun to hate the hassle of connecting to a new wifi service in every new harbor; I’m done with it.

While I love to geek-out on my boat in this case I went with a text message driven system instead (Boat Command – Ben mentioned in 5/23 article) and couldn’t be happier with it. I bought it impulsively as a boat show special three years ago not quite sure what I was getting. It’s become one of those rare products that delights me in its power and simplicity every time I interact with it. Every three hours it sends a text message to its server with a status about my boat (battery status of two banks, bilge pumps runs, temperature, location, shore power status, intruder detect, more) and I can access that data easily by app or pc. If an alarm setting is triggered (e.g.: too many pump runs, or intruder) then I get a text immediately. I can also force an immediate update any time I want. My solar trickle charger easily keeps up with the tiny power consumption. I’ve used this in New England waters and it’s worked flawlessly and without a single adjustment everywhere I cruise. I sailed my boat to Bermuda for the America’s Cup in June and left her there for the summer and continue to get all the status updates. What peace of mind! I head to the Caribbean in the fall and will leave the boat there at times and know I’ll stay informed, hassle free. All for $9 a month. It’s the perfect answer for my needs.

Posted by: Jovini at July 20, 2017 9:07 AM | Reply

Agreed, Jovini, that Boat Command is a well designed system and a good value. Here's the main Panbo writeup:

http://www.panbo.com/archives/2016/03/boat_command_remote_vessel_monitoring_for_the_app_age.html

But I'll be really interested to hear if BC works well for you around the Caribbean as I'm skeptical about "global GSM" cell claims (largely because at least one doesn't work here in Camden, Maine, though there is GSM coverage and BC works fine here).

It may turn out that it often makes some sense to have a WiFi based monitoring system and then, if need be, to use a separate cell product to keep it connected in a difficult locale. Or Iridium ;-)

At any rate, the FloatHub Kickstarter campaign got past the 2/3rds funded mark, but only has 24 hours left. It's going to be close:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/modiot/floathub

Posted by: Ben in reply to Jovini at July 21, 2017 7:50 AM | Reply

the same canoe done with the new Victron Venus PLUS there will lNOT be monthly charges

Posted by: Anonymous at July 22, 2017 2:30 AM | Reply

Ben, in regards to Wi-Fi and Cell. Here is a solution.

I have a Pepwave MAX BR1 with Wi-Fi (LAN) and it has two slots for sim cards. I have an AT&T GSM sim card in one of the slots. You can "set" which you want as primary and secondary source for the Wi-Fi.

I have a Coastal Marine Wi-Fi with a Ubiquiti 24 V PoE injector wired into the Pepwave as my (Wan) source.

Also have a Wilson Amp connected to an outside antenna then connected to the PepWave.

So, loss of Wi-Fi, PepWave would auto switch to AT&T Cell signal. WORKS GREAT. The Apps of Pepwave and Coastal Marine on an i-Pad, makes life really easy.

Bob Wilkins

Posted by: Robert Wilkins at July 22, 2017 4:06 PM | Reply

OK, looks good...but will this be yet another recurring monthly fee for cloud storage? Such fees were nickel-and-diming me to death, and I've eliminated all but essentials.

Off topic, but how about an article on Anderson PowerPole DC connectors, or, have you already covered them? They seem to be under-utilized in the marine world, yet are a staple in the communications industry. (feel free to edit/delete this paragraph) https://powerwerx.com/anderson-power-powerpole-sb-connectors

Posted by: Karl at July 23, 2017 1:13 PM | Reply

Anon, actually the Victron Venus (or Color Control GX) could give me much better off boat power monitoring than the FloatHub because it can integrate with Victron current sensors, solar panel controllers and inverter/chargers:

http://www.panbo.com/archives/2017/04/news_victron_venus_cruzpro_sog2_dy_windsense_vaavud_ultrasonic_panbo_news.html

And while it's great that Victron includes the cloud monitoring at no extra charge, you do have to purchase a number of Victron components to get the most out of it.

Posted by: Ben in reply to Anonymous at July 25, 2017 9:03 AM | Reply

Thanks, Robert, but I'm jealous. I'd like a setup like yours and Coastal Marine WiFi just lent me their PepWave SOTG router, which integrates cellular data with their EasyBullet WiFi app. Info is somewhat hidden on their order page:

https://www.coastalmarinewifi.com/Order.aspx

https://www.coastalmarinewifi.com/CellularSetup.htm

But so far AT&T seems unwilling to activate a SIM card because they don't like my billing address (it's a roaming area for them) though I'd mostly use it south of here. Sigh.

Posted by: Ben in reply to Robert Wilkins at July 25, 2017 9:14 AM | Reply

Karl, as wrote (and linked to) in the entry, the FloatHub service plans "happily start at $0 per month":

https://floathub.com/plan/pricing

As for Anderson Powerpole connectors, I love them! Just about every marine electronics device installed on Gizmo gets Powerpoles installed on the 12v cable, often going to a RIGrunner fused distribution box like this:

https://powerwerx.com/west-mountain-radio-rigrunner-4008h-horizontal

I'm not sure that they make sense for "permanent" installs but they hold up fine in my experience and they let me easily do things like test current draw, as you can see about half way down this entry:

http://www.panbo.com/archives/2017/06/raymarine_axiom_lh3_a_little_fishing_then_the_install.html

Posted by: Ben in reply to Karl at July 25, 2017 9:51 AM | Reply

Ben, as we all know, it seems that the wireless companies have rules that they use and some that they do not. AND, mostly it has to do with the person at the AT&T store.

My AT&T account has a Sewell, NJ billing address. I have (2) i-pads (2) i-phones (1) "hot spot" and now the AT&T sim card in the Pepwave.

And, I had the Sim card activated in Brunswick, ME (Cooks Corner) just south of Bath, ME. They just added the sim card to my account, for "I think" $15.00 per month. All these devises share the "MEG plan" that I have.

So, just an FYI as to how I got my sim card activated.

Robert Wilkins
Bruckmann Abaco 40 (Bella)
Lying at beautiful Great Island Boat Yard in Harpswell. ME.

Posted by: Robert Wilkins in reply to Ben at July 26, 2017 12:08 PM | Reply

Leave a comment